Science Research Homepage
|
|
Chemistry 2009
Summer Science Research Abstract
|
|
Analysis of the different mobilities of K-turn RNA and Base-paired RNA
Elena Brunner
Mentor: Dr. Susan White
Ribonucleic acid (RNA) allows for the production of proteins, which aid in the cellular growth and regulation, through the utilization of the genetic coding present in DNA during transcription and the processing and editing of the RNA structure during splicing. The double stranded structure of the RNA customarily consists of the Watson-Crick base-pairing of the purine and pyrimidine nucleotides—hydrogen bonds between adenine-uracil, and guanine- cytosine. However, the nucleotides may not pair traditionally; one example among many is helix-internal loop-helix motif (the kink-turn motif). The internal loop consists of a strand of unpaired nucleotides, which follows a Watson-Crick base-paired stem and precedes a non-Watson Crick base-paired stem. Advances in the understanding of the structure and binding affinities of the K-turn in comparison to those of the Watson-Crick representative RNA (base-paired RNA) enhance the understanding of the RNA-protein interactions.
To test mobility of the kink-turn and base-paired RNA, we will utilize Analytical Ultracentrifugation and Gel Filtration Chromatography. Using Analytical Ultracentrifugation, sedimentation experiments can extract the rate of migration and possibly be used in the determination of shape as the RNA settles in solution. The rate of sedimentation is dependent on the shape and density of the molecule, as each differently sized molecules settle at different minimal centrifugal forces—dense, spherical molecules sediment at a more rapid rate, while elongated molecules at a slower rate. Our hope is to determine whether kink-turn and base-paired RNAs sediment differently in the presence of Mg2+. We will test the Analytical Ultracentrifugation with Mg2+ in solution with the kink-turn and base-paired RNA to determine any difference in mobility of the two forms of RNA. When binding to Mg2+, kink-turn RNA is assumed to be bent and “folded over,” suggesting a more rapid sedimentation than the base-paired RNA, which is more elongated. The gel filtration chromatography allows for analysis of mobility in the two RNA forms through chromatography columns. Greater mobility depends on the more condensed shape of the molecule traveling through the column. Our hope is to determine whether the kink-turn and base-paired RNAs have different mobilities through the columns. If there is a difference, is magnesium and heat required to maintain that difference? Testing this approach with both forms of RNA with and without the presence of magnesium at two main temperatures, we predict that the K-turn RNA, having a “folded over structure” will have a greater mobility than the base-paired RNA. Both the analytical centrifugation and the gel filtration chromatography help to determine the size relationship between the two forms of the RNA, and indirectly aid in the determination of structure and binding capabilities.
|
Anna Giatarrana
Mentor: Dr. Bill Malachowski
Cancer is a disease that affects millions of people worldwide, and is the 2nd leading cause of deaths in the United States. It is thought that indolamine deoxyhydrogenase oxide (IDO) plays a role in immunosuppression, allowing tumors to grow in the body undetected. It has been shown that IDO inhibitors are able to slow the progress the cancer in conjunction with chemotherapy. By using computer modeling, molecules that may be more potent inhibitors than those that currently exist have been proposed. The purpose of thus study is to find synthetic methods to create these molecules in fewer steps and greater yield.
|
The Synthesis of a [7]Phenacene Derivative as a Molecular Wire
Ariana Hall
Mentor: Dr. Frank Mallory
Phenacenes, or graphene ribbons, are molecules containing [n] aromatic rings joined in a zigzag pattern. Because pseudo one-dimensional graphene ribbons are similar to pseudo two-dimensional graphene sheets, they may have similar conductive properties, and so could be used as bridges for electron transport within molecules. Studies have previously been reported at Northwestern University using bridges made of benzene rings connected in the pattern shown below:

Unlike these bridges, where the rings are rotated at angles to one another, phenacenes are planar, and so may conduct electrons differently and possibly more effectively. This experiment will attempt to synthesize molecules with n=7 aromatic rings in the phenacene bridge. The phenacenes will have a bromine substituted on one end, and an amine substituted on the other end. They will also have a solubilizing alkyl group substituted on either end, as shown below: R=
The synthesis involves multiple reactions, including Grignard, Horner-Emmons, bromination and photocyclization reactions to build the molecules. If the phenacenes are successfully constructed, their conductive properties as bridges will be further studied.
|
June Mbae
Mentor: Dr. Frank Mallory
Conjugated systems have demonstrated their ability to act as electron shuttles and as such may be used as a molecular wire that transfers electrons from an electron donor to an electron acceptor. [n]phenacenes, which are compounds with n benzene rings fused together in an extended zig-zag pattern, have such a conjugated system and could therefore be used to test its utility as a molecular wire. In addition, linked benzene rings have previously been used as molecular wires in a donor-bridge-acceptor molecular complex and as such, the effectiveness of such a wire and that of [n]phenacenes can be experimentally compared. This is especially of interest within the field of nanotechnology. To allow these comparisons, the synthesis of previously unknown [3]phenacenes will be undertaken and the most efficient synthetic path will be thusly determined. In future, the synthesis of [n]phenacenes with n greater than 3 will allow a study into the effectiveness of larger phenacenes as molecular wires and thus increasing our understanding on the chemical characteristics of the said phenacenes.
|
Implementing the Birch-Cope Sequence and Rearrangement for the Synthesis of Natural Therapies
Sharan Kaur Mehta
Mentor: Dr. Malachowski
Within the scope of organic synthesis, the goal of attaining biologically active compounds has proven its extensive value as well as its array of strategic challenges, specifically in the creation of enantiomerically pure carbocyclic quaternary stereocenters. However, the implementation of the three-stage Birch-Cope sequence, comprising of the Birch reduction-allylation, enol ether hydrolysis, and Cope rearrangement has become a proven method of effectively generating such chiral stereocenters, which are crucial synthetic intermediates. Expanding on the procedure’s prior successes, its discovery has stimulated a wealth of synthetic opportunity in the ultimate hopes of developing innovative therapies in the way of antibiotics, which the Malachowski research team currently seeks to explore. Within the scheme of the project, my role this summer specifically involves the production of the o-anisic acid derivative starting material possessing a chiral auxiliary, which is derived from a reaction with L-prolinol. Longer range goals include conducting the Birch-Cope sequence and contributing to the exploration of the product after the Cope rearrangement.
Synthesis of o-anisic acid derivative with chiral auxiliary:

Birch-Cope Sequence and Rearrangement:

|
The Synthesis of a Solubilized [11]Phenacene Derivative
Kim Mullane
Mentor: Dr. Frank Mallory
[n]Phenacenes are molecules containing n aromatic rings joined together in a zigzag pattern. Since they can be thought of as graphene ribbons, which have conductive properties, they should have the potential to be used as molecular wires. The solubility of unsubstituted [n]phenacenes decreases dramatically with increasing n; [7]phenacene was found by the Mallory group to have negligible solubility. Currently the longest known [n]phenacene is an [11]phenacene derivative that was synthesized by the Mallory group with tert-butyl substituents acting as solubilizing groups, but it was found to have only modest solubility. The goal of my research is the synthesis of the [11]phenacene derivative shown below. The purpose is to test whether the long-chain alkyl groups R can provide the necessary solubility to allow the synthesis of even larger [n]phenacenes with n = 15 and n = 19.

The planned 15-step route for the synthesis of this compound involves a sequence of different types of chemical reactions, including Grignard, Friedel-Crafts, bromination, Arbuzov, Horner-Wadsworth-Emmons, and photocyclization reactions.
|
Modeling the Molybdenum Cofactor: An Exercise in Synthesis
Alison Panosian
Mentor: Dr. Sharon Burgmayer
Molybdenum is a metallic trace element and is necessary for the functioning of most living organisms. Molybdenum is found naturally in lima beans, spinach, grains, and peas. In humans, a deficiency of molybdenum can lead to health problems, since molybdenum enzymes catalyze many important processes. For example, the enzyme sulfite oxidase utilizes the molybdenum cofactor (Moco) when it transforms sulfite to sulfate via a redox reaction. Allowing the body to metabolize sulfur containing amino-acids, the failure of this reaction can cause neurological disorders. Moco is found in almost all of the molybdenum enzymes in humans is critical to biological reactions. The cofactor consists of a dithiolene organic complex coupled with a molybdenum. The chemistry of the molybdenum cofactor is unknown, and synthesizing model Moco compounds will help one understand the bioinorganic chemistry of molybdenum enzymes.
To create Moco requires the convergence of two synthetic pathways. The first is a seven-step process creating the pterinyl alkynes. The pterin is a heterocyclic compound composed of a pyrazine ring and a pyrimidine ring, containing a carbonyl oxygen and an amino group. Once the pterin is synthesized, a series of anaerobic reactions are performed to add the alkyne. The other pathway creates the tetrasulfide molybdenum complex through three steps resulting in the oxidation of molybdenum by adding sulfur ligands. The pterinyl alkyne reacts with tetrasulfide molybdenum complex resulting in the synthesis of a molybdeunum pterinyl-dithiolene complex to mimic these cofactors. These products will be characterized by FT-IR, NMR and mass spectroscopy. The goal of this research is to follow both synthetic pathways, developed by the Burgmayer laboratory, in an effort to develop the model molybdenum cofactor.
|
Synthesis of functionalized cis-fused bicarbocyclic structures via olefin cross metathesis and tandem conjugate/Michael addition
Yuan Qiao
Mentor: Dr. Bill Malachowski
Syntheses of cis-fused bicarbocyclic systems are of great interest for constructing complex organic architectures. We report a new synthetic method to functionalized bicarbocyclic structures using the final product from the Birch-Cope sequence that has been developed by the Malachowski group. The two-step method (Scheme 1) includes an olefin cross metathesis and a tandem conjugate/Michael addition.

A wide range of olefin cross metathesis alkenes and a variety of conjugate addition nucleophiles are explored to illustrate the versatility of this synthetic strategy. The alkenes (Table 1) chosen are commercially available and all have precedent for their use in olefin metathesis. It has been shown that 2.5mol% of second generation Hoveyda-Grubb’s catalyst afforded excellent yields with the listed alkenes. The nucleophiles (Table 1) for tandem conjugate/Michael addition come in several forms: non-stabilized carbon nucleophiles, stabilized carbon nucelophiles, heteroatom nucleophiles and carbon radicals. Our work demonstrates the accessibility of constructing functionalized cis-fused bicarbocyclic structures using this tool.

|
Visualization of the Kink-Turn Structure of RNA
Mithila Rajagopal
Mentor: Dr. Susan White

X-ray and NMR Refined structure of Yeast L-30e-mRNA Complex. (Chao, 2004) 1
RNA, like proteins, folds into 3D structures, consisting of motifs such as hairpins, pseudoknots, and internal loops. This research project focuses on visualizing one such motif, which is called the kink-turn. The kink-turn region consists of Watson-Crick base pairs on either end of a short asymmetric bulge that consists of non-base paired nucleotides, which results in a sharp bend in the phosphodiester backbone. This region is of particular interest because it has been found that proteins bind to RNA selectively at this region. The figure above shows the yeast L30e protein binding to the kink-turn region of its m-RNA. The biophysical structure characterization of the kink-turn of RNA would thus give information about the nature of this motif and its importance in protein-RNA interactions. Such research will aid in studying potentially useful protein-RNA interactions as well as construction of RNA molecular units capable of self-assembling into RNA nanostructures. The goal of this research is to use Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) to visualize and characterize RNA molecules that have a kink-turn.
For this purpose, previous work done in the lab involved the construction of a relatively large molecule of double stranded RNA with a kink-turn. Two different sequences of 9 and 6 nucleotides respectively were inserted into commercially provided plasmid using site-directed mutagenesis. Linearization of DNA containing these sequences and subsequent transcription with T7 RNA polymerase resulted in the production of RNA that was approximately 900 nucleotides in length. The region of insertion, because it contained non-complementary sequences, resulted in a kink-turn in the RNA molecule. This molecule is large enough to be visualized with the AFM and to study the degree of bending caused by the kink-turn accurately.
Currently, we are focusing on exploring the technique of atomic force microscopy and using it to visualize DNA samples in order to arrive at a method of sample preparation that is suitable for our goals. The most common way of preparing samples is to use functionalized mica surfaces on which the molecules of interest have been immobilized. This general method has to be made specific to our RNA molecules. Further experiments will involve the visualization of kink-turn and non kink-turn RNA molecules in dry as well as liquid environments, and studying the effect of protein (L30e-Maltose Binding Protein) and metal-ions (Mg2+) on the degree of bending of the kink-turn. It is expected that the protein will bind to the kink-turn region and that this will be visible in the AFM images. It is also anticipated that this will change the degree of bending of the kink-turn and we hope to be able to make accurate measurements of the angle of bending.
1 Chao, J A, Williamson, J R. Joint X-Ray and NMR Refinement of Yeast L-30e-mRNA Complex. Structure. (2004). 12(7): 1165-1176
|
Analysis and Comparison of Kink-Turned and Base-Paired RNA
Ashton A. Shaffer
Mentor: Dr. Susan A. White
Ribonucleic acid (RNA) is an essential macromolecule in biological systems. The tertiary structure of the RNA is critical because it directs protein recognition and binding which in turn enables functions like regulation. When RNA is double stranded, it typically adopts a helical structure that consists of traditional Watson-Crick base pairing in which hydrogen bonds form between the nitrogenous bases guanine-cytosine and adenine-uracil. In some instances, the structure of the helix is interrupted by a sharp bend, known as a kink-turn. Kink-turned RNA consists of two asymmetrical strands with nucleotides that base pair without conforming to Watson-Crick rules and usually contains three nucleotides that are unpaired altogether. The proteins that interact with kink-turned RNA are specifically structured to chemically recognize its unique shape and interact with it to form protein-RNA complexes. We intend to study the characteristics of kink-turned RNA in comparison to base-paired RNA in order to better understand how RNA-protein complexes form and function.
Our purpose is to experimentally compare kink-turned (KT) and base-paired (BP) RNA using a variety of different methods. First, we will synthesize and purify both variants (KT and BP) and use a method called analytical ultracentrifugation to perform sedimentation experiments, which utilize fluid dynamic properties to distinguish between differently structured substances. Secondly, we will perform chromatography experiments to determine whether or not the kink-turn affects the mobility of the RNA in the columns. Next, we will perform thermodynamic denaturation experiments to differentiate the relative stabilities of the two types of RNA. Finally, we will employ atomic force microscopy to better visualize the actual structural differences between KT and BP RNA. For each of these individual experiments, we will also test whether or not the presence of magnesium salts affect the shape or motility of the RNAs. Our ultimate goal is to be able to collect information about the structure and behavior of KT RNA by comparing it to BP RNA using the aforementioned methods. By substantiating our knowledge of the characteristics of kink-turned RNA, we will be better able to understand RNA-protein interactions in general and how structural differences affect their behavior and biological functioning.
|
Allison Shatz
Mentor: Dr. Sharon Burgmayer
Heterocyclic Ruthenium complexes have been shown to be DNA intercalators. These planar compounds contain carbon-nitrogen aromatic rings that insert between AT and GC base pairs of DNA. The Ruthenium compounds used are tri-chelated Ru (II) compounds. The basic structure includes two 2,2-bipyridine and a varying third ligand, phen-alloxazine, phen-aminopteridine, phen-dimethylalloxazine, phen-diaminopteridine, and phen-pterin. Upon exposure to UV light, many of the Ruthenium compounds have been shown to cleave DNA. Results of varying concentration and UV exposure time is explored through gel electrophoresis to determine optimal conditions, observe quenching and to elucidate ligand effects. Cleavage mechanism is largely unclear, though reactive oxygen species (ROS) are suspected. Investigating the effects of different ROS inhibitors, such as dimethylsulfoxide, superoxide dismutase, and sodium azide, will hopefully provide insight into the mechanism. DNA intercalation is confirmed using viscosity experiments. A parallel investigation is also being conducted with Copper and Cobalt complexes. Initial investigation into toxicity is also being conducted on cancer cell lines. Because of their ability to be selectively activated upon ultraviolet exposure, these complexes have potential future applications in cancer therapy.
|
Stephanie Vrakas
Dr. Sharon Burgmayer
Metals are crucial for many biological reactions due to the fact that they are functionally versatile. Transition metals can be employed as biological catalysts, used as a means to transport molecules or ions, and function as the structural backbone of a compound. In order to better understand the complexity of transition metals and their complexes, model compounds are often used. Molybdenum is a transition metal that is present in many biological enzymes. Although there are many different molybdenum containing enzymes that function to control the redox activity of a variety of substrates, all molybdenum enzymes contain a molybdenum cofactor (Moco). The Burgmayer group has developed an innovative model for the Moco, which incorporates many of the vital structural elements that are present in all Mo enzymes. The Moco model is a molybdenum dithiolene complex is synthesized via the convergence of two synthetic pathways with the reaction of a molybdenum polysulfido compound with a pterinyl alkyne. The goal of this particular research was the synthesis of the molybdenum polysulfido compound and the alkyne reagents. The molybdenum polysulfido compound is also known as ‘tetrasulfide’. Tetrasulfide was synthesized effectively in two steps, in which Mo0 was oxidized to MoIV through the addition of sulfur to produce a tetrasulfide ligand. The pterinyl alkyne was synthesized effectively in seven steps. The first six steps created the pyrimidine and pyrazine rings that together are the pterin framework. In the seventh step an alkyne was combined with the pterin framework via a Sonogashira cross coupling reaction. Spectroscopic techniques such as H1 NMR, infrared spectroscopy and mass spectroscopy were all used to confirm the identities of the various compounds. The ability to effectively synthesize the compounds precedes the next step of constructing the Moco model. Through these reactions the Burgmayer group will be able to continue studying the reactivity and chemical nature of molybdenum enzymes, which hopefully will lead to a greater understanding about how the Moco enzyme functions within biological systems.
|
|
|